On Wednesday's GFB: Lisa Thompson - January 23rd

Jan 22, 2013

By Dale Goldhawk

Share on

11:30am ET | Lisa Thompson, MPP, Huron-Bruce
12:15pm ET | George Marcello, CEO Step By Step

GUEST – Lisa Thompson, MPP, Huron-Bruce

TOPIC – Open Letter from MPP Lisa Thompson to Dr. Arlene King, Chief Medical Officer of Health.

INFO – OPEN LETTER – January 21, 2013

Dr. Arlene King, Chief Medical Officer of Health,
Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care,
11th Flr., Hepburn Block, 80 Grosvenor St.,
Toronto, ON M7A 1R3

Dear Dr. King:

I am writing to you today to express my growing apprehension over the revelations arising from recent Freedom of Information requests that were released. In November 2012, emails from the Ministry of the Environment, released through the FOI process, reveal that provincial field officers had confirmed adverse health effects from wind turbine noise as far back as 2009, and were working on an abatement plan to assist affected residents. The released documents indicate that, in response to a redacted email from government staff, the MOE officers agreed to stand down.

I also have concerns with another FOI document I received, in which Q&A’s were prepared in response to your report, The Potential Health Effects of Wind Turbines. In one section of these Q&A’s, the track changes indicated that you should “add the word direct as studies would show a link through annoyance.” As the Chief Medical Officer of Health, I am sure you are aware that the World Health Organization has determined that annoyance is a health effect of wind turbines.

In another section of the Q&A’s document, this statement was made in relation to health and wind turbines: “there are no known indirect links.” Except, in the track changes comment box it said, “Not really true. The link between perceived noise and symptoms is probably linked to annoyance. The link with annoyance should be recognized.

The last section I would like to draw your attention to is one more Q&A. One answer stated: “Although some people living near wind turbines report symptoms such as dizziness, headaches and sleep disturbance, available scientific evidence does not demonstrate a causal link to wind turbines noise.” The track changes of this comment tells a different story, where you were told, “this answer isn’t credible. Either fess up to the annoyance link or delete.

Dr. King, Dr. Gloria Rachamin acknowledged under oath in the Kent Breeze wind farm case that your study did not look at the indirect health effects of wind turbines. These indirect health effects are the ones that cause the sleeplessness, depression, dizziness, headaches among other health problems.

I am asking you today to acknowledge publicly that your report did not study the indirect health effects of wind turbines. I also have many questions surrounding not only your report, but health complaints that were received by either the Ministry of the Environment, Energy or Health and Long-Term Care. For one, did the Ministry of Environment advise your office that complaints about wind turbines and health were being received? Were you contacted to investigate any of these complaints? Why were any of the reports from MOE field officers in 2009 not included in your 2010 report?

Respectfully, I ask that you review your 2010 report for clarifications between the direct/indirect link between wind turbines and health effects. I can respectfully acknowledge that the likelihood of a wind turbine blade falling off and hurting someone (a direct link) is highly improbable, but the valid health effects (indirect links) need to be studied so we can help families who have been displaced from their homes and are dealing with serious health consequences. I am sure that we can agree that the health and well-being of Ontario families is first and foremost for both of us.

I appreciate your time to review my correspondence, and I and many Ontario families await your response.


Lisa Thompson, MPP Huron-Bruce


GUEST – George Marcello, CEO Step By Step, and advocate for Organ & Tissue donation

TOPIC – Canada has one of the lowest organ donation rates in the world, and the charity- Step By Step, is presently helping 28 year old Anthony Socci receive a much needed kidney transplant.

George Marcello, has been an advocate for Organ & Tissue donations for almost 20 years. His charity – Step By Step, alerted Canada to this issue, and he has been involved in every policy change for Organ Donations. He is well versed on the organ donation system in Canada and around the world.

George Marcello’s, main priority is to help 28 year old Anthony Socci receive his kidney transplant, as his charity has helped hundreds of others in the past.

Step By Step is helping Anthony do this with a project called Anthony’s Hero. A young man of 21 years of age will be carrying the famous Torch of Life, in an 18 day marathon from Ottawa to Toronto. Starting Feb 5 in Ottawa and finishing in Toronto Feb 22. The Torch of Life which was blessed by Pope John Paul 2, and the entire marathon will be filmed live on the charities website, http://www.torchoflife.com/ .

Time permitting, he will also discuss Lifesavers Act – a new proposal to address the present shortage of organ donations in Canada.

NOTE – Almost two thirds of the 1,529 Ontarians awaiting a life-saving transplant are age 50 and older,
but only 39 per cent of the 2.5 million registered organ and tissue donors fall in that age group, – Quoted from Barbara Turnbull; Toronto Star

Advertise With Us

To learn about advertising opportunities with Zoomer Radio use the link below:

Join Our Fan Club
Coverage Area
Downtown Toronto
Toronto HD
96.3 HD-2
Kingston to Windsor, Parry Sound to Pittsburgh
ZoomerRadio Logo

Recently Played: